Just to prove that the fame (minimal) and fortune (non-existant) has not gone to my head since my breaking the news of what really happened in Jose Canseco's Boxing Controversy (linked on both Yahoo and Deadspin), I have bent to my league's demands (and since I have nothing better to write about) to provide my league's preseason fantasy baseball rankings.
12. John
Summary: This team is so boring, you may fall asleep while reading through the roster.
The Good: For some reason, I really like his Baltimore Orioles picks. Even though he is going over to the tougher league in a less ideal ballpark, Mark Reynolds crushes the ball. If he can get his batting average up to .250, he's a huge asset at third base which is not a position with a lot of depth. I also like Hardy to have a good year as he had to deal with a wrist injury last year, so I think he can show some of the power that he displayed during his Milwaukee days. Also, Ricky Nolasco's fantasy stats have to match his advanced stats eventually, right?
The Bad: There seemed to be a ton of draft picks that lacked upside. Werth, Pence, Hart, and Walker all seem like pretty boring picks. I'm also not real high on Logan Morrison being a great fantasy option in his first full year. Same goes for David Murphy, because, well, he's David Murphy. If everything goes right, it's a middle of the pack team, but unless this team gets immaculate luck, this is not a championship caliber team.
11. Chad
Summary: At least he won't be short on steals. Unfortunately, every other category could be a problem.
The Good: He got Albert Pujols, I hear he's good. He also got Zimmerman when a pick finally came back around to him. I could also see Aaron Hill having a bounceback year this season. Getting Francisco in the last round is a really nice pick since Toronto has said that he has the closer's job when he comes off the disabled list. And for some reason, even though it makes no sense as I'm typing it, I kind of like Carlos Lee to be good again this year. Somebody on the Astros has to be good, right?
The Bad: He drafted Michael Bourn and Brett Gardner back to back, so he must really like steals. When you take Adam LaRoche, you've clearly stopped caring. He's also depending on Rafael Furcal staying healthy at shortstop and can't be expecting much at catcher with Kurt Suzuki behind the plate. This is another team that just fails to excite me.
10. DW
Summary: Things didn't start well, and they didn't end well either, but there was a solid middle.
Good: Jose Reyes and Brian McCann back to back are really good picks for the fourth and fifth rounds. Yes, Reyes is an extreme risk, but he is in a contract year and he might just explode this year. If he's healthy, it's great, but it could still bite him in the ass. Shortstop is a very shallow position, so having somebody with this much upside is great to have. McCann is nearly the opposite. He is low risk. Worst case is that he's an above average catcher, but he has the potential to be the top catcher in the league. I also like B-Rob as a good late value who can really pay off if he's healthy or you can drop him when he has yet another horrible injury.
Bad: Roy Halladay at number three is bad. He could be the best pitcher in the league and still be a regrettable pick at number three. Casey McGehee doesn't excite me in any way. Brian Wilson seems like a guy who is due to regress this year, and he's already hurt which isn't a good sign to start the year. Also, the Justin Smoak pick is simply a waste of a pick.
9. Cory
Summary: Cory's an old soul, so he drafted a bunch of grizzled vets for his fantasy team.
The Good: I really like his first two picks. Hanley's one of the few five category studs, and Prince Fielder has a lot of hitting talent around him, so there's no reason he can't produce big numbers this season. Another pick I really liked was Curtis Granderson as he actually started hitting lefties last year, so if he can mash righties like he has in the past, he could put up a monster season. On the pitching side, I think James McDonald is the kind of guy you want to take a chance on late in the draft as he put up really good numbers at the end of last year, but it is still a small sample size. Maybe it works great, or maybe he's an early drop, but it's good to have the chance to find out.
The Bad: Joey Bats at 26 is not the type of chance I would want to take off of one season's work. I don't see him falling off the face of the Earth, but I also see him more at 30 home runs than the 50 he hit last year. I also don't really like the Aubrey Huff pick, because Aubrey Huff has killed me in fantasy in the past, and when I finally gave up on him, he started hitting again. This might just be me being bitter, but I have some serious issues with Huff, and I really don't think he'll put up the numbers he had last year. I'm also not high on Brad Lidge as I'm pretty sure he's thrown his arm off and it may never come back.
8. JVD
Summary: We all hate JVD. I'm glad his team will suck.
The Good: I'm not gonna lie, I love Troy Tulowitzki. I wish I could somehow disparage everything in this draft, because this JVD character is the punching bag of the entire league. But while we're on the good, I also really like Josh Johnson as I thought he was underrated going into this season. Later in the draft, he made some nice picks with Geovany Soto, Pablo Sandoval, and Brett Anderson.
The Bad: Outside of their team owner being a douche, this draft completely fell apart down the stretch. Tyler Colvin? Regression year. Aroldis Chapman? Setup man, whoopty doo. Ryan Raburn? Who? Michael Pineda? Growing pains. A lot of people will also have problems with Mike Stanton in the third round, but if you really want a guy and you don't think he'll be around later, then you go for it, and it's not like Stanton isn't loaded with potential. Also, the Latos, Morales, Zobrist streak were all questionable decisions. I'm betting against all three. And finally, did I mention their owner is a douche?
7. Mike D
Summary: Taking a glance at this team, you'd be surprised they're ranked this low. If you knew Mike D, you wouldn't be.
The Good: I really like some of the mid-round values that he found. Two that stand out are Gordon Beckham and Carlos Pena. Beckham was a huge disappointment last year, but he actually started hitting well towards the end of the season. Pena is moving to the weaker league and a hitter's ballpark, so 40 home runs is definitely a possibility. I also like Chone Figgins and Manny Ramirez late as they are two guys who could also have bounceback years in 2011.
The Bad: Although his pitching is strong, I think Lincecum went too high. He had ups and downs last year and pitched a ton of innings last year. I can see him showing the wear of last year during this season. I'm not a big Jacoby Ellsbury fan, because he's going to have to battle for playing time. It doesn't seem like the Red Sox are exactly in love with the guy, so I could see them pulling the plug on him very early. And on top of that, he's injury prone. Ian Desmond seemed like a desperation pick to just get some sort of a shortstop out there, and at that point I probably would have waited towards the end to just see what was left out there.
Tomorrow, we go over the contenders now that we're done with these pretenders.
12. John
Summary: This team is so boring, you may fall asleep while reading through the roster.
11 | Joey Votto, Cin 1B |
14 | Kevin Youkilis, Bos 1B |
35 | Jayson Werth, Was OF |
38 | Zack Greinke*, Mil SP |
59 | Hunter Pence, Hou OF |
62 | Corey Hart, Mil OF |
83 | Stephen Drew, Ari SS |
86 | Max Scherzer, Det SP |
107 | Mark Reynolds, Bal 3B |
110 | Neil Walker, Pit 2B |
131 | Ricky Nolasco, Fla SP |
134 | Miguel Montero, Ari C |
155 | Drew Storen, Was RP |
158 | Andres Torres, SF OF |
179 | Jonny Venters, Atl RP |
182 | Logan Morrison, Fla OF |
203 | Dexter Fowler, Col OF |
206 | Ricky Romero, Tor SP |
227 | Brandon Lyon, Hou RP |
230 | David Murphy, Tex OF |
251 | J.J. Hardy, Bal SS |
The Bad: There seemed to be a ton of draft picks that lacked upside. Werth, Pence, Hart, and Walker all seem like pretty boring picks. I'm also not real high on Logan Morrison being a great fantasy option in his first full year. Same goes for David Murphy, because, well, he's David Murphy. If everything goes right, it's a middle of the pack team, but unless this team gets immaculate luck, this is not a championship caliber team.
11. Chad
Summary: At least he won't be short on steals. Unfortunately, every other category could be a problem.
1 | Albert Pujols, StL 1B |
24 | Cliff Lee, Phi SP |
25 | Ryan Zimmerman, Was 3B |
48 | Jason Heyward, Atl OF |
49 | Tommy Hanson, Atl SP |
72 | Heath Bell, SD RP |
73 | Roy Oswalt, Phi SP |
96 | Aaron Hill, Tor 2B |
97 | Michael Bourn, Hou OF |
120 | Brett Gardner, NYY OF |
121 | Rafael Furcal, LAD SS |
144 | Francisco Cordero, Cin RP |
145 | Brandon Morrow, Tor SP |
168 | Adam LaRoche, Was 1B |
169 | Anibal Sanchez, Fla SP |
192 | Carlos Lee, Hou OF |
193 | Ian Kennedy, Ari SP |
216 | Edwin Jackson, CWS SP |
217 | Raul Ibanez, Phi OF |
240 | Kurt Suzuki, Oak C |
241 | Frank Francisco, Tor RP |
The Bad: He drafted Michael Bourn and Brett Gardner back to back, so he must really like steals. When you take Adam LaRoche, you've clearly stopped caring. He's also depending on Rafael Furcal staying healthy at shortstop and can't be expecting much at catcher with Kurt Suzuki behind the plate. This is another team that just fails to excite me.
10. DW
Summary: Things didn't start well, and they didn't end well either, but there was a solid middle.
3 | Roy Halladay, Phi SP |
22 | Nelson Cruz, Tex OF |
27 | Ryan Howard, Phi 1B |
46 | Jose Reyes, NYM SS |
51 | Brian McCann, Atl C |
70 | Yovani Gallardo, Mil SP |
75 | Brian Wilson, SF RP |
94 | Howard Kendrick, LAA 2B |
99 | Casey McGehee, Mil 3B |
118 | Clay Buchholz, Bos SP |
123 | Adam Jones, Bal OF |
142 | Madison Bumgarner, SF SP |
147 | Jose Valverde, Det RP |
166 | Vernon Wells, LAA OF |
171 | C.J. Wilson, Tex SP |
190 | Brian Roberts, Bal 2B |
195 | Jake Westbrook, StL SP |
214 | Kyle Drabek, Tor SP |
219 | Justin Smoak, Sea 1B |
238 | Denard Span, Min OF |
243 | Jair Jurrjens, Atl SP |
Good: Jose Reyes and Brian McCann back to back are really good picks for the fourth and fifth rounds. Yes, Reyes is an extreme risk, but he is in a contract year and he might just explode this year. If he's healthy, it's great, but it could still bite him in the ass. Shortstop is a very shallow position, so having somebody with this much upside is great to have. McCann is nearly the opposite. He is low risk. Worst case is that he's an above average catcher, but he has the potential to be the top catcher in the league. I also like B-Rob as a good late value who can really pay off if he's healthy or you can drop him when he has yet another horrible injury.
Bad: Roy Halladay at number three is bad. He could be the best pitcher in the league and still be a regrettable pick at number three. Casey McGehee doesn't excite me in any way. Brian Wilson seems like a guy who is due to regress this year, and he's already hurt which isn't a good sign to start the year. Also, the Justin Smoak pick is simply a waste of a pick.
9. Cory
Summary: Cory's an old soul, so he drafted a bunch of grizzled vets for his fantasy team.
2 | Hanley Ramirez, Fla SS |
23 | Prince Fielder, Mil 1B |
26 | Jose Bautista, Tor 3B |
47 | Victor Martinez, Det C |
50 | Chris Carpenter, StL SP |
71 | Jered Weaver, LAA SP |
74 | Paul Konerko, CWS 1B |
95 | Curtis Granderson, NYY OF |
98 | Torii Hunter, LAA OF |
119 | Kelly Johnson, Ari 2B |
122 | Ted Lilly, LAD SP |
143 | Aubrey Huff, SF 1B |
146 | Daniel Hudson, Ari SP |
167 | Adam Lind, Tor DH |
170 | Bobby Abreu, LAA OF |
191 | Brad Lidge, Phi RP |
194 | Trevor Cahill, Oak SP |
215 | Fernando Rodney, LAA RP |
218 | James McDonald, Pit SP |
239 | Brandon McCarthy, Oak SP |
242 | Jorge De La Rosa, Col SP |
The Bad: Joey Bats at 26 is not the type of chance I would want to take off of one season's work. I don't see him falling off the face of the Earth, but I also see him more at 30 home runs than the 50 he hit last year. I also don't really like the Aubrey Huff pick, because Aubrey Huff has killed me in fantasy in the past, and when I finally gave up on him, he started hitting again. This might just be me being bitter, but I have some serious issues with Huff, and I really don't think he'll put up the numbers he had last year. I'm also not high on Brad Lidge as I'm pretty sure he's thrown his arm off and it may never come back.
8. JVD
Summary: We all hate JVD. I'm glad his team will suck.
7 | Troy Tulowitzki, Col SS |
18 | Josh Hamilton, Tex OF |
31 | Mike Stanton, Fla OF |
42 | Ichiro Suzuki, Sea OF |
55 | Josh Johnson, Fla SP |
66 | Mat Latos, SD SP |
79 | Kendry Morales, LAA 1B |
90 | Ben Zobrist, TB 2B |
103 | Geovany Soto, ChC C |
114 | Pablo Sandoval, SF 3B |
127 | Brett Anderson, Oak SP |
138 | Chris Perez, Cle RP |
151 | Jordan Zimmermann, Was SP |
162 | Tyler Colvin, ChC OF |
175 | Andrew Bailey, Oak RP |
186 | Aroldis Chapman, Cin RP |
199 | Ryan Raburn, Det OF |
210 | Michael Pineda, Sea SP |
223 | Derek Holland, Tex SP |
234 | Brandon League, Sea RP |
247 | Derek Lowe, Atl SP |
The Bad: Outside of their team owner being a douche, this draft completely fell apart down the stretch. Tyler Colvin? Regression year. Aroldis Chapman? Setup man, whoopty doo. Ryan Raburn? Who? Michael Pineda? Growing pains. A lot of people will also have problems with Mike Stanton in the third round, but if you really want a guy and you don't think he'll be around later, then you go for it, and it's not like Stanton isn't loaded with potential. Also, the Latos, Morales, Zobrist streak were all questionable decisions. I'm betting against all three. And finally, did I mention their owner is a douche?
7. Mike D
Summary: Taking a glance at this team, you'd be surprised they're ranked this low. If you knew Mike D, you wouldn't be.
6 | Carlos Gonzalez, Col OF |
19 | Tim Lincecum, SF SP |
30 | Jon Lester, Bos SP |
43 | Buster Posey, SF C |
54 | Dan Haren, LAA SP |
67 | Jacoby Ellsbury, Bos OF |
78 | Francisco Liriano, Min SP |
91 | Carlos Marmol, ChC RP |
102 | Gordon Beckham, CWS 2B |
115 | Carlos Pena, ChC 1B |
126 | Carlos Quentin, CWS OF |
139 | Ian Desmond, Was SS |
150 | Ian Stewart, Col 3B |
163 | Edwin Encarnacion, Tor 3B |
174 | Manny Ramirez, TB OF |
187 | Ryan Dempster, ChC SP |
198 | Chone Figgins, Sea 2B |
211 | Angel Pagan, NYM OF |
222 | Derrek Lee, Bal 1B |
235 | Grady Sizemore, Cle OF |
246 | David Aardsma, Sea RP |
The Bad: Although his pitching is strong, I think Lincecum went too high. He had ups and downs last year and pitched a ton of innings last year. I can see him showing the wear of last year during this season. I'm not a big Jacoby Ellsbury fan, because he's going to have to battle for playing time. It doesn't seem like the Red Sox are exactly in love with the guy, so I could see them pulling the plug on him very early. And on top of that, he's injury prone. Ian Desmond seemed like a desperation pick to just get some sort of a shortstop out there, and at that point I probably would have waited towards the end to just see what was left out there.
Tomorrow, we go over the contenders now that we're done with these pretenders.
-Joe
P.S. Sad about the Bulls losing to the Sixers? This may be a few days old, but it will cheer you up.