Last night was the annual Beer Drinkers Fantasy Baseball draft between my longtime friends and I, and I wanted to review each round to give you the highs and lows. If you haven't drafted yet, this type of information can be extremely helpful in making sure that you have a fantasy baseball team nearly as good as mine. Here are the teams and owners (half are fairly obvious):
Team Arp - Chris A
Stinky Hangdown - Mike D
Team Roy - Jason R
Team Ehrecke - Cory E
Team CP - Hott Joe
Beginners Luck - Chad P
Team Vertical Smile - Bryan B
Team Pussylicker - Brad P
Team Waite - Danny W
Team Here4Beer - Scott S
Team Asay - Mike A
Team Prayer - Jon VD
Also, excitement started even before the draft when Asay and I swapped our first two round picks, giving him picks 5 and 20, while I received picks 11 and 14.
Best Picks - Hanley Ramirez falling to three is a very good pick as well as Chase Utley going at fifth.
Worst Picks - Carl Crawford at number seven doesn't excite me. Also, Tim Lincecum at nine is a little scary since his velocity has been down this spring.
Best Pick - Justin Upton. I had to decide whether I would go with Longoria and Tulowitzki or Upton, and I finally decided a little before the draft that Tulowitzki had more value since there just wasn't much talent at short. Upton has the potential to be the number one fantasy hitter this year. He really is that good, so for him to fall to 21 was a steal.
Worst Pick - Jacoby Ellsbury at 17 is a big reach. Stolen bases aren't as scarce as they were 3-5 years ago, so you can get steals late, and I wouldn't have touched Ellsbury in the first five rounds.
Best Pick - Grady Sizemore. He's still a young guy and if he can get his average up, he's going to be a fantasy monster. I think he has a much better year than last year.
Worst Pick - It was inevitable, but drafting a guy who is injured every year and who is very good, not great, is not a good idea. Peck loves A-Ram, so he really had no choice.
Best Picks - BJ Upton and Brian McCann. I love the Upton brothers, so it's very disappointing that I was unable to find a good time to select either one of them, but I do expect both of them to have great years this year. Also, Brian McCann had eye troubles last year and still put up good numbers. I think he will have a year similar to his great 2008.
Worst Picks - Another homeboy pick in B-Rob probably wasn't a smart decision, but he's been DW's boy forever, so I understand the pick. He's getting up there in age and I could see a significant decline this year. Also, I'll admit that I could be completely off on this one, but Ben Zobrist has never really shown that he was a great player when he was coming up through the minor leagues. He was great last year, and he may have turned a corner, but I would rather wait another year on a guy like that to see if he's the real deal or a flash in the pan.
Best Pick - This was a very well drafted round from top to bottom, but I like the Johan Santana pick the most. I was drafting him if he fell to me there (although I still have a fantasy hard-on for Adam Jones), but there's a chance that he is the best pitcher in baseball this year, so to get him in the fifth round is a definite steal.
Worst Pick - Again, this was a well drafted round, but I'd have to go with Stephen Drew, even though I love him since he has a brother in pro baseball (I'm a sucker for brothers). I understand the pick because the shortstop position is pretty shallow, but this is too early to be gambling on a guy not only bouncing back, but exceeding what he did in his good year.
Best Picks - Gordon Beckham - Beckham has enough of a bat to be a very good third baseman. The fact that he is playing second base this year only sweetens the deal on him. Chase Utley's a monster, but I wouldn't be surprised if Beckham was the second most valuable second baseman this year (especially with Kinsler already being hurt).
Worst Pick - Carlos Zambrano - Another homer pick from Peck. I think he'll be better than last year, but I don't think he's a top 100 pick, much less number 65.
Best Pick - Clayton Kershaw - As long as he stays healthy, he could lead the league in strikeouts. He could take the next step and become an elite pitcher this year.
Worst Picks - Tough call as I hate a lot of these picks, Ubaldo Jimenez is inexcusable with Hanson and Kershaw still on the board. The same could be said with Brandon Webb, since he is still struggling with his shoulder and Kershaw was still there for the taking. Plus, it seems a little early for good-fielding middle infielders like Elvis Andrus and Asdrubal Cabrera. Bad round for my friends on this one.
Best Picks - Manny Ramirez and Cole Hamels - Manny has a contract year. Although I think the contract year is blown way out of proportion (and studies have shown I'm right), if there is anybody who might focus a little harder and really give it his all during a contract year, it's definitely Manny. Also, Cole Hamels was a guy who had a lot of bad luck last year, but since his luck wasn't as bad as Nolasco's, he didn't get much publicity for it. I don't expect him to be better than Roy Halladay, but it also wouldn't shock me.
Worst Pick - Michael Young - He's old and not a middle infielder anymore, so I see the decline that everybody predicted last year happening this year. Third base is a very shallow position, so I understand panicking and selecting him here.
Best Pick - Adam Dunn - Every year, this guy falls in the draft, and he pretty much produces every year. The move to Washington didn't hurt his stats last year, and there's no reason to expect a big decline this year either. I don't think there will be much difference between him and Adrian Gonzalez when it comes to hitting.
Worst Pick - Since there's really not much difference between closers, I'd say the worst pick was Derrek Lee. Given the choice between the three first basemen taken in this round, Lee is significantly behind the other two in my book.
Best Picks - I'm giving a little bit of a gift here, but since I critiqued these guys earlier for picking their boys, I'll celebrate their picks for this round. Colby Rasmus is a young guy who I think is ready to take a big step forward this year. Also, with catcher being a weak position, I think Soto's potential makes him a very good pick here. He let himself get out of shape, and came back in shape this year. He could turn out to be very good value here.
Worst Pick - Nolan Reimold - Reimold is solid, but if you look at the other outfielders taken after him, guys like Choo, Rasmus, Beltran, and Quentin, I just don't see his potential being higher than any of those guys, nor has he established himself as a consistent producer. It looks like JVD realized he didn't have enough young guys and panicked with this pick.
That's rounds 1-10. I'll be doing rounds 11-21 later this week.
-Joe
P.S. This is enjoyable for anyone.
Team Arp - Chris A
Stinky Hangdown - Mike D
Team Roy - Jason R
Team Ehrecke - Cory E
Team CP - Hott Joe
Beginners Luck - Chad P
Team Vertical Smile - Bryan B
Team Pussylicker - Brad P
Team Waite - Danny W
Team Here4Beer - Scott S
Team Asay - Mike A
Team Prayer - Jon VD
Also, excitement started even before the draft when Asay and I swapped our first two round picks, giving him picks 5 and 20, while I received picks 11 and 14.
| ROUND 1 | ||
| 1 | Albert Pujols, StL 1B | Team Arp |
| 2 | Alex Rodriguez, NYY 3B | Stinky Hangdown |
| 3 | Hanley Ramirez, Fla SS | Team Roy |
| 4 | Ryan Braun, Mil OF | Team Ehrecke |
| 5 | Chase Utley, Phi 2B | Team Asay |
| 6 | Prince Fielder, Mil 1B | Beginners Luck |
| 7 | Carl Crawford, TB OF | Team Vertical Smile |
| 8 | Miguel Cabrera, Det 1B | Team Pussylicker |
| 9 | Tim Lincecum, SF SP | Team Waite |
| 10 | Matt Kemp, LAD OF | Team Here4Beer |
| 11 | Troy Tulowitzki, Col SS | Team Cunt Pounder |
| 12 | Joe Mauer, Min C | Team Prayer |
Worst Picks - Carl Crawford at number seven doesn't excite me. Also, Tim Lincecum at nine is a little scary since his velocity has been down this spring.
| ROUND 2 | ||
| 13 | Roy Halladay, Phi SP | Team Prayer |
| 14 | Evan Longoria, TB 3B | Team Cunt Pounder |
| 15 | Mark Teixeira, NYY 1B | Team Here4Beer |
| 16 | David Wright, NYM 3B | Team Waite |
| 17 | Jacoby Ellsbury, Bos OF | Team Pussylicker |
| 18 | Felix Hernandez, Sea SP | Team Vertical Smile |
| 19 | Ian Kinsler, Tex 2B | Beginners Luck |
| 20 | Ryan Howard, Phi 1B | Team Asay |
| 21 | Justin Upton, Ari OF | Team Ehrecke |
| 22 | CC Sabathia, NYY SP | Team Roy |
| 23 | Jimmy Rollins, Phi SS | Stinky Hangdown |
| 24 | Matt Holliday, StL OF | Team Arp |
Worst Pick - Jacoby Ellsbury at 17 is a big reach. Stolen bases aren't as scarce as they were 3-5 years ago, so you can get steals late, and I wouldn't have touched Ellsbury in the first five rounds.
| ROUND 3 | ||
| 25 | Dustin Pedroia, Bos 2B | Team Arp |
| 26 | Grady Sizemore, Cle OF | Stinky Hangdown |
| 27 | Zack Greinke, KC SP | Team Roy |
| 28 | Adrian Gonzalez, SD 1B | Team Ehrecke |
| 29 | Joey Votto, Cin 1B | Team Cunt Pounder |
| 30 | Ryan Zimmerman, Was 3B | Beginners Luck |
| 31 | Dan Haren, Ari SP | Team Vertical Smile |
| 32 | Aramis Ramirez, ChC 3B | Team Pussylicker |
| 33 | Pablo Sandoval, SF 3B | Team Waite |
| 34 | Robinson Cano, NYY 2B | Team Here4Beer |
| 35 | Cliff Lee, Sea SP | Team Asay |
| 36 | Derek Jeter, NYY SS | Team Prayer |
Worst Pick - It was inevitable, but drafting a guy who is injured every year and who is very good, not great, is not a good idea. Peck loves A-Ram, so he really had no choice.
| ROUND 4 | ||
| 37 | Justin Morneau, Min 1B | Team Prayer |
| 38 | Justin Verlander, Det SP | Team Asay |
| 39 | B.J. Upton, TB OF | Team Here4Beer |
| 40 | Brian Roberts, Bal 2B | Team Waite |
| 41 | Brandon Phillips, Cin 2B | Team Pussylicker |
| 42 | Kevin Youkilis, Bos 3B | Team Vertical Smile |
| 43 | Adam Wainwright, StL SP | Beginners Luck |
| 44 | Brian McCann, Atl C | Team Cunt Pounder |
| 45 | Jon Lester, Bos SP | Team Ehrecke |
| 46 | Ben Zobrist, TB 2B | Team Roy |
| 47 | Ichiro Suzuki, Sea OF | Stinky Hangdown |
| 48 | Victor Martinez, Bos C | Team Arp |
Worst Picks - Another homeboy pick in B-Rob probably wasn't a smart decision, but he's been DW's boy forever, so I understand the pick. He's getting up there in age and I could see a significant decline this year. Also, I'll admit that I could be completely off on this one, but Ben Zobrist has never really shown that he was a great player when he was coming up through the minor leagues. He was great last year, and he may have turned a corner, but I would rather wait another year on a guy like that to see if he's the real deal or a flash in the pan.
| ROUND 5 | ||
| 49 | Jose Reyes, NYM SS | Team Arp |
| 50 | Johan Santana, NYM SP | Stinky Hangdown |
| 51 | Mark Reynolds, Ari 3B | Team Roy |
| 52 | Chris Carpenter, StL SP | Team Ehrecke |
| 53 | Adam Jones, Bal OF | Team Cunt Pounder |
| 54 | Stephen Drew, Ari SS | Beginners Luck |
| 55 | Andre Ethier, LAD OF | Team Vertical Smile |
| 56 | Adam Lind, Tor OF | Team Pussylicker |
| 57 | Josh Beckett, Bos SP | Team Waite |
| 58 | Yovani Gallardo, Mil SP | Team Here4Beer |
| 59 | Jayson Werth, Phi OF | Team Asay |
| 60 | Josh Johnson, Fla SP | Team Prayer |
Worst Pick - Again, this was a well drafted round, but I'd have to go with Stephen Drew, even though I love him since he has a brother in pro baseball (I'm a sucker for brothers). I understand the pick because the shortstop position is pretty shallow, but this is too early to be gambling on a guy not only bouncing back, but exceeding what he did in his good year.
| ROUND 6 | ||
| 61 | Ricky Nolasco, Fla SP | Team Prayer |
| 62 | Curtis Granderson, NYY OF | Team Asay |
| 63 | Billy Butler, KC 1B | Team Here4Beer |
| 64 | Jonathan Broxton, LAD RP | Team Waite |
| 65 | Carlos Zambrano, ChC SP | Team Pussylicker |
| 66 | Kendry Morales, LAA 1B | Team Vertical Smile |
| 67 | Nick Markakis, Bal OF | Beginners Luck |
| 68 | Gordon Beckham, CWS 3B | Team Cunt Pounder |
| 69 | Josh Hamilton, Tex OF | Team Ehrecke |
| 70 | Chone Figgins, Sea 3B | Team Roy |
| 71 | Jason Bay, NYM OF | Stinky Hangdown |
| 72 | Javier Vazquez, NYY SP | Team Arp |
Worst Pick - Carlos Zambrano - Another homer pick from Peck. I think he'll be better than last year, but I don't think he's a top 100 pick, much less number 65.
| ROUND 7 | ||
| 73 | Ubaldo Jimenez, Col SP | Team Arp |
| 74 | Tommy Hanson, Atl SP | Stinky Hangdown |
| 75 | Nelson Cruz, Tex OF | Team Roy |
| 76 | Mariano Rivera, NYY RP | Team Ehrecke |
| 77 | Jay Bruce, Cin OF | Team Cunt Pounder |
| 78 | Brandon Webb, Ari SP | Beginners Luck |
| 79 | Clayton Kershaw, LAD SP | Team Vertical Smile |
| 80 | Elvis Andrus, Tex SS | Team Pussylicker |
| 81 | Yunel Escobar, Atl SS | Team Waite |
| 82 | Matt Cain, SF SP | Team Here4Beer |
| 83 | Matt Wieters, Bal C | Team Asay |
| 84 | Asdrubal Cabrera, Cle 2B | Team Prayer |
Worst Picks - Tough call as I hate a lot of these picks, Ubaldo Jimenez is inexcusable with Hanson and Kershaw still on the board. The same could be said with Brandon Webb, since he is still struggling with his shoulder and Kershaw was still there for the taking. Plus, it seems a little early for good-fielding middle infielders like Elvis Andrus and Asdrubal Cabrera. Bad round for my friends on this one.
| ROUND 8 | ||
| 85 | Michael Young, Tex 3B | Team Prayer |
| 86 | Chad Billingsley, LAD SP | Team Asay |
| 87 | Manny Ramirez, LAD OF | Team Here4Beer |
| 88 | John Lackey, Bos SP | Team Waite |
| 89 | Carlos Lee, Hou OF | Team Pussylicker |
| 90 | Aaron Hill, Tor 2B | Team Vertical Smile |
| 91 | Andrew McCutchen, Pit OF | Beginners Luck |
| 92 | Cole Hamels, Phi SP | Team Cunt Pounder |
| 93 | Jason Heyward, Atl OF | Team Ehrecke |
| 94 | Hunter Pence, Hou OF | Team Roy |
| 95 | Jonathan Papelbon, Bos RP | Stinky Hangdown |
| 96 | Jake Peavy, CWS SP | Team Arp |
Worst Pick - Michael Young - He's old and not a middle infielder anymore, so I see the decline that everybody predicted last year happening this year. Third base is a very shallow position, so I understand panicking and selecting him here.
| ROUND 9 | ||
| 97 | Adam Dunn, Was 1B | Team Arp |
| 98 | Derrek Lee, ChC 1B | Stinky Hangdown |
| 99 | Francisco Rodriguez, NYM RP | Team Roy |
| 100 | Joakim Soria, KC RP | Team Ehrecke |
| 101 | Heath Bell, SD RP | Team Cunt Pounder |
| 102 | Andrew Bailey, Oak RP | Beginners Luck |
| 103 | Brian Wilson, SF RP | Team Vertical Smile |
| 104 | Roy Oswalt, Hou SP | Team Pussylicker |
| 105 | Francisco Cordero, Cin RP | Team Waite |
| 106 | Alexei Ramirez, CWS SS | Team Here4Beer |
| 107 | Carlos Pena, TB 1B | Team Asay |
| 108 | Carlos Gonzalez, Col OF | Team Prayer |
Worst Pick - Since there's really not much difference between closers, I'd say the worst pick was Derrek Lee. Given the choice between the three first basemen taken in this round, Lee is significantly behind the other two in my book.
| ROUND 10 | ||
| 109 | Nolan Reimold, Bal OF | Team Prayer |
| 110 | Shin-Soo Choo, Cle OF | Team Asay |
| 111 | Jose Valverde, Det RP | Team Here4Beer |
| 112 | Colby Rasmus, StL OF | Team Waite |
| 113 | Geovany Soto, ChC C | Team Pussylicker |
| 114 | Carlos Beltran, NYM OF | Team Vertical Smile |
| 115 | Carlos Quentin, CWS OF | Beginners Luck |
| 116 | Clay Buchholz, Bos SP | Team Cunt Pounder |
| 117 | Jose Lopez, Sea 2B | Team Ehrecke |
| 118 | Jair Jurrjens, Atl SP | Team Roy |
| 119 | A.J. Burnett, NYY SP | Stinky Hangdown |
| 120 | Juan Pierre, CWS OF | Team Arp |
Worst Pick - Nolan Reimold - Reimold is solid, but if you look at the other outfielders taken after him, guys like Choo, Rasmus, Beltran, and Quentin, I just don't see his potential being higher than any of those guys, nor has he established himself as a consistent producer. It looks like JVD realized he didn't have enough young guys and panicked with this pick.
That's rounds 1-10. I'll be doing rounds 11-21 later this week.
-Joe
P.S. This is enjoyable for anyone.



